Reindeer as Recruiters: Which Working Style Fits Your Team?
Santa's sleigh only works because the reindeer pull together.
A recruitment desk is much the same: one person closes fast, another keeps clients calm, another finds the candidate nobody else spotted. This holiday-themed exercise gives your team eight friendly labels for those differences — and a practical way to check whether the mix actually covers the work.
How to use the reindeer labels
Treat the eight names as conversation starters, not as a formal personality test. The point is to make it easier to say what each person brings to a desk, a client relationship or a hiring sprint — and where the team is thin.
A simple way to run it:
- Read the eight descriptions below and ask each person to pick the one or two that sound most like their working day.
- Ask them to name one task where that style helps and one where it gets in the way.
- Map the answers against your current open roles and client commitments.
- Look for gaps: if everyone is fast, who is checking the details? If everyone is charming on client calls, who is chasing the difficult candidates?
- Agree one small change — a pairing, a handover or a review step — rather than a full reorganisation.
The labels are deliberately broad. A recruiter who is quick under pressure may also be the one who remembers a candidate's name months later. That overlap is normal, and the FAQ below addresses it.
1. Dasher — fast and reliable under pressure
Dasher is the quick one: results arrive on time, multiple tasks run in parallel and deadlines rarely slip. Candidates and clients both respond well to that pace.
Useful question for your team: when the week is overloaded, who is keeping the promised dates? And who is checking that speed has not cost quality?
Watch-out: a fast desk can leave the quieter follow-up work — feedback, notes, candidate care — to someone else. Pair a Dasher with a detail-focused colleague on complex roles.
2. Prancer — polished and team-minded
Prancer is the recruiter who turns up prepared, presents well to clients and keeps morale up. That combination makes them a natural point of contact in meetings and a steady support for colleagues.
Useful question for your team: who is setting the tone in client meetings, and who is checking that the team behind the scenes is being looked after?
Watch-out: polish can hide overload. Make sure the person carrying the room also has someone carrying their admin.
3. Cupid — strong on candidate and client experience
Cupid is the matchmaker: good at connecting people, attentive to how candidates and clients feel, and careful that nobody is treated as just another record in the system.
Useful question for your team: who is protecting the candidate experience when the desk is busy? And who is checking that a good match is also a good fit for the client?
Watch-out: care work is easy to under-count. If the Cupid on your team is also doing all the follow-up calls, that is a workload issue, not just a personality trait.
4. Donner — persuasive in the room
Donner can sell a difficult role, hold a room at a recruitment event and keep a client confident through a long search. Confidence and presence are the core strengths here.
Useful question for your team: who is best placed to present a hard-to-fill role or run a client briefing? And who is checking the promises made in that room against what the delivery team can actually do?
Watch-out: persuasion needs a reality check. Pair the strongest presenter with someone who owns the delivery plan.
5. Rudolph — potential that shows up later
Rudolph starts quietly, then becomes the person whose difference turns into an advantage. In a recruitment team that often looks like someone who has not yet had the right role, client or stretch assignment.
Useful question for your team: who has not yet been given a chance to lead something? What would a small stretch project show us?
Watch-out: do not mistake quietness for lack of ambition. The Rudolph label is a prompt to look for untapped potential, not a reason to leave someone on the sidelines.
6. Vixen — creative problem-solver
Vixen generates options: new ways to write an advert, unusual sourcing routes, fresh formats for team sessions. When a role has stalled, this is the person who suggests a different angle.
Useful question for your team: which stalled role or client problem would benefit from a fresh approach this month?
Watch-out: ideas need an owner. Give the creative colleague a partner who can turn the best idea into a repeatable process.
7. Blitzen — energy and momentum
Blitzen brings pace and morale when deadlines tighten and the team is tired. That energy keeps people focused through a difficult hiring period.
Useful question for your team: who lifts the room during a crunch, and who is checking that the crunch does not become permanent?
Watch-out: sustained intensity is not a substitute for rest. Rotate the high-energy roles so the same person is not always the one carrying the sprint.
8. Comet — trust-builder
Comet turns hesitation into agreement by connecting personally. That is valuable with candidates who are weighing an offer and with clients who need reassurance before a difficult hire.
Useful question for your team: which relationships depend on a personal connection, and what happens if that person is on leave?
Watch-out: trust held by one person is fragile. Document the key relationships so the team is not exposed when someone is away.
Team coverage checklist
Use this as a quick audit after the exercise. Tick the areas your team genuinely covers, then note who covers each one.
- Speed and deadline reliability — who keeps promised dates?
- Client-facing polish — who represents the agency in meetings?
- Candidate care — who follows up when a candidate goes quiet?
- Persuasion — who can sell a difficult role or brief?
- Hidden potential — who has not yet been given a stretch task?
- Creative problem-solving — who suggests a different approach when a role stalls?
- Energy during crunch — who keeps the team moving, and who protects recovery time?
- Relationship continuity — who holds key client and candidate trust, and is it documented?
If two or three areas have no clear owner, that is the practical output of the exercise. It is more useful than deciding which single reindeer 'wins'.
A small worked example
Imagine a four-person agency with three open roles and a client briefing on Friday.
- One recruiter is fast and reliable on deadlines — the Dasher.
- One is polished and handles the client meeting — the Prancer.
- One is strong on candidate care and keeps people warm through a long process — the Cupid.
- One is creative and suggests a new sourcing route for the hardest role — the Vixen.
The gap is not obvious from the labels alone. Nobody in the group is clearly the trust-builder for the hesitant final candidate, and nobody has been given the stretch task that would reveal a Rudolph. The team could pair the Cupid with the Vixen on the difficult role, and give the quietest member the Friday briefing prep as a small stretch assignment.
That is the level of decision the exercise is designed to support: small, specific and reversible.
What this exercise is not
This is a team-language exercise, not a validated psychometric assessment. It does not measure performance, predict hiring success or replace a structured interview or appraisal. Use it to start a conversation about coverage and strengths, then make decisions with your normal review process.
It is also not a reason to label someone permanently. The descriptions are broad on purpose, and most recruiters will recognise themselves in more than one.
Frequently asked questions
Can these traits be used to inspire team-building activities?
Yes. The reindeer labels work well as a light way to talk about what each person brings to the team and where the group is thin. A holiday meeting is a natural moment to assign labels, highlight contributions and build a bit of camaraderie — as long as the exercise stays a conversation starter rather than a formal assessment.
What if I don't fit any one of the above reindeer profiles?
You are probably a hybrid. Recruitment asks for versatility, so it is normal to recognise traits from several reindeer. That mix is what makes you useful to a team, and it is worth naming in the exercise rather than forcing yourself into a single label.
How can I develop traits like empathy or creativity if I don’t naturally have them?
Start small. Empathy grows through practice — for example, active listening in an interview or a client call. Creativity grows through deliberate exploration: brainstorm new sourcing routes or try a new tool. Over time those habits become part of how you recruit.
Is this a formal personality test?
No. The eight labels are a holiday-themed conversation tool for naming working styles and checking team coverage. They are not a validated psychometric instrument and should not be used for selection, promotion or appraisal decisions on their own.