Skip to content

Retained Search vs Contingency Recruiting: How to Choose a Fee Model

Agencies usually get paid in one of two ways: a client commits to a search up front, or you compete for a placement and invoice only if your candidate is hired.

The choice changes your cash flow, how much competition you face and how deeply you can search. This guide sets out how each model works, the fee ranges commonly quoted, and a practical way to pick between them for a specific vacancy.

What retained search involves

: Retained search begins with the client approaching a search agency to fill a vacancy. The engagement is contractual, and the recruiter is paid a share of an agreed fee before the placement is complete.

  • Who it is for: senior and executive roles such as CEO, Vice President, CTO, CXO or CMO. Junior roles are rarely handled this way.
  • Why confidentiality matters: a company replacing a senior leader usually will not post the role on public job boards. It briefs a trusted search firm to approach candidates discreetly instead.
  • How it pays: agencies on this model typically charge around 20–30% of the candidate's salary, usually in three instalments — one third on signing the contract, one third when an offer is made, and the final third when the candidate joins. Niche or rare searches can command more.
  • What it gives the recruiter: income that does not depend entirely on a single placement closing, and freedom from a very tight deadline, which allows a thorough search.
  • What it costs: it is not the fastest or cheapest route, but it supports finding strong candidates and building a reputation in the market.

A useful way to picture it: if a large consumer brand needed a new marketing chief, it would more likely brief an executive search firm privately than advertise the opening on Glassdoor, LinkedIn or Monster.

What contingency recruiting involves

In contingency search, the recruiter is paid only when the candidate they put forward is hired and actually starts the job. The shorthand for this is "no win, no fee".

  • Competitive by design: agencies work for clients on demand, and several may be chasing the same role. There is usually no exclusive contract and the arrangement is transactional. Whoever places a suitable candidate first gets paid.
  • The risk: because payment is not guaranteed, this model carries more uncertainty for the agency. One practitioner, Louise Archer of Retrained Search, has estimated that recruiters spend roughly 80% of their time on work that never produces a fee.
  • Typical roles: low to mid-level positions.
  • How it pays: fees are commonly around 12–30% of the candidate's first annual salary, and there is usually a set contingency period within which you must find a suitable candidate.
  • The upside for candidate relationships: candidates can see that you are working to a deadline and are as motivated as they are to land the role.

Side-by-side: how the two models differ

The table below summarises the practical differences described above. Fee percentages are the ranges quoted in this guide and should be treated as a general reference point, not a fixed market rate — confirm current norms with your own clients and contracts.

Which model is better?

Neither model wins outright; the right answer depends on the vacancy and on your agency's appetite for risk.

Contingency search is less secure than retained search. With no guaranteed income attached to a given role, building an agency entirely on contingency work is the riskier path. If your agency focuses on junior roles or candidates at the lower end of the salary spectrum, however, contingency can be a very good fit — and retained search would be overkill.

Retained work brings its own advantages beyond the fee. Interviewing candidates one-to-one and working alongside a client's senior managers and executives gives you a deeper view of the people you place and builds relationships with the company that can pay off later. It is more expensive for the client, but the upfront payment provides security, and recruiters can realistically double or triple revenue using the same resources.

A checklist for choosing a fee model

Work through these questions before you quote a client:

  1. How senior is the role? Executive and C-level vacancies point towards retained search; junior and mid-level roles usually suit contingency.
  2. Does the client need confidentiality? If the vacancy cannot be advertised publicly, a retainer-based search is the natural fit.
  3. Can the client commit budget up front? Retained work depends on a client willing to pay in stages before the hire is complete.
  4. How much unpaid work can you absorb? Contingency means competing, sometimes against several agencies, with no payment unless your candidate starts.
  5. Is the search niche or rare? Unusually specialised briefs can justify a higher retained fee.
  6. What is your time window? Contingency engagements come with a deadline; retained searches allow a more thorough process.
  7. What relationship do you want afterwards? Retained work tends to put you in front of senior client stakeholders, which can open future briefs.

Worked example: what a retained fee looks like in stages

The figures below are illustrative only — they apply the quoted 20–30% range and the three-stage split to a hypothetical salary so you can see the cash-flow shape. They are not a quote for any client.

Assume an agreed fee equal to 25% of a candidate salary of 100,000 in your currency:

  • Total fee: 25,000
  • On signing the contract: about 8,333
  • When an offer is made: about 8,333
  • When the candidate joins: about 8,333

Compare that with a contingency placement at, say, 20% of the same first-year salary: 20,000, received only after the candidate is hired and starts. The retained route spreads income across the search and reduces dependence on a single closing event; the contingency route pays later but requires no upfront client commitment.

Two different kinds of failure

It helps to separate the risks, because they are not the same problem.

  • Contingency failure is unpaid effort. You may do the work and lose the placement to a faster agency, or the candidate may not start. The cost is time and opportunity, not a refund.
  • Retained failure is cost and pace. The client pays more and may wait longer for the hire, and the agency carries the expectation of a thorough, confidential search rather than a quick shortlist.

Naming which risk you are actually managing makes the model choice much clearer than treating one as simply "better".

What to record for each engagement

Whichever model you use, capture the commercial terms in one place so invoicing and reporting stay consistent:

  • Fee basis (percentage of salary) and the agreed percentage
  • Payment stages and the trigger for each stage
  • Whether the engagement is exclusive
  • The contingency period or search timeline
  • Role seniority and confidentiality requirements
  • Candidate start confirmation, which is the trigger for the final payment in a retained search and for any payment in a contingency search

Retained search vs contingency recruiting at a glance
DimensionRetained searchContingency recruiting
How the engagement startsClient approaches the agency; contractual basisClient engages agencies on demand; transactional, usually non-exclusive
When the recruiter is paidIn stages: on contract signing, on offer, and on the candidate joiningOnly if the candidate is hired and shows up for the job
Typical feeAround 20–30% of the candidate's salary; more for niche searchesAround 12–30% of the candidate's first annual salary
Typical seniorityCEO, VP, CTO, CXO, CMO and similar senior rolesLow to mid-level positions
ConfidentialityHigh — roles are rarely advertised publiclyLower — multiple agencies may be working the same role
Time pressureNot bound by a tight time frameA contingency period applies
Main risk for the agencyHigher cost to the client and a slower processUnpaid work if another agency places first or the candidate does not start

Fee ranges are the figures quoted in this guide and are a general reference, not a current market rate; verify terms with clients and contracts.

Frequently asked questions

What does "no win, no fee" mean in contingency recruiting?

It means the recruiter is paid only if the candidate they find is successfully hired and starts the job. If the placement does not happen, no fee is due.

Can a retained search be used for junior roles?

It is rarely done. Retained search is normally reserved for higher-level positions such as CEO, Vice President, CTO, CXO or CMO, and is unusual for junior vacancies.

How is a retained fee usually split?

Commonly into three parts: one third when the contract is signed, one third when an offer is made, and the final third when the candidate joins the company.

Why is contingency recruiting considered riskier for agencies?

Because there is no guaranteed income attached to the work. Several agencies may compete for the same role, there is usually no exclusive contract, and payment depends entirely on a successful hire and start.

Does retained search mean the recruiter has no deadline at all?

Retained search is not bound by a tight time frame, which allows a thorough search — but the client still expects the vacancy to be filled, and the staged payments create their own milestones.