Six Recruiting Practices Worth Copying
Recruiting advice is easy to collect and hard to act on.
This guide takes six practices associated with well-known talent-acquisition voices and turns each into something a team can adopt: a decision to make, a signal to watch and a way to tell whether it is working. Use the checklist to choose one starting point rather than attempting all six at once.
Start with the decision, not the skill list
The first practice is associated with Lou Adler and is usually called performance-based hiring. The core move is to describe the job as a set of outcomes the person must deliver, then interview against those outcomes instead of against a checklist of technologies or titles.
A practical way to run it: write down the two or three results the hire must produce in the first year, and for each one note what evidence would convince you a candidate has produced something comparable before. The interview then becomes a search for that evidence.
Adler's suggested opening question shows the technique in action. The evidence you need sits in the follow-up, not the headline answer: once a candidate names the single project or task they regard as their most significant career accomplishment, the rest of the interview goes into the particulars of how they pulled it off and the obstacles they ran into. A couple of minutes of answer is enough to open that conversation, and the probing that follows is where you learn whether the person can actually do the job.
Decide whether you need a data wonk or a reporting analyst
Rob McIntosh's argument is that many talent-acquisition teams talk about improvement but lack someone whose job is to make the data useful. He calls that person a data wonk. The distinction matters because the two roles are often conflated.
A conventional reporting analyst pulls numbers out of the applicant tracking system or CRM and hands them over. A data wonk goes further: they test whether the numbers are valid, look for what is likely to happen next, and challenge assumptions that the team has stopped questioning. McIntosh's point is that the second kind of person is what unblocks change.
Before hiring for either role, decide which problem you actually have. If leaders cannot get consistent numbers at all, a reporting analyst may be enough. If the numbers arrive but nobody trusts them or acts on them, the gap is the data wonk's job.
Replace feel-good numbers with funnel ratios
Kyle Lagunas's advice is to stop measuring activity that only shows how busy recruiters are. Volume of calls, number of profiles reviewed and similar counts can look healthy while telling you nothing about whether hiring is improving.
Instead, break the hiring funnel into stages and compare the ratios between them. Lagunas points to comparisons such as sourcing strategy against phone screening, and screening against whether an offer was extended and accepted. Each ratio tells you where candidates are dropping out, which is the information you need to change something.
A simple way to begin: pick one role family, list the stages from first contact to accepted offer, and record how many candidates pass each stage over a fixed period. The ratios between consecutive stages are your baseline. Lagunas's wider point is that recruitment teams have historically under-tracked this kind of measurement, and that being consistent about it is what makes a team data-driven rather than merely data-aware.
Build trust deliberately during disruption
Josh Bersin's lesson from the pandemic period is that a cultural shift was already underway and teams needed to keep pace with it. His emphasis is on relationships, care and trust as the foundation, rather than on morale-boosting gestures.
Bersin treats trust as three qualities held together. Competence means the team reliably does the right things well. Ethics means fairness and honesty are maintained. Listening means staying genuinely open to feedback and advice. A workplace decorated with motivational posters does not supply any of those three. They have to be demonstrated in how decisions are made and how people are treated.
He also stresses flexibility, freedom and room for enjoyment, and the value of optimism as a practical posture rather than a slogan. For a recruiting team, that translates into how you handle a missed placement, a client change of brief or a candidate who withdraws late: the response is the evidence of the culture you claim to have.
Make candidate experience survive scale
Meghan M. Biro's observation is that engaging candidates well is the hardest part of the work, and that it matters more as more of the relationship happens online and at the interview stage.
A small agency with one or two strong recruiters can usually deliver a good experience through personal attention. The problem appears when the team grows: the quality of treatment stops being carried by individual talent and has to be built into the process. That is the point at which candidate experience becomes a design question rather than a personality trait.
Biro also notes the commercial side. Whether or not a particular candidate is hired, a positive experience can produce better word of mouth, and that reflects on the agency's brand. The practical implication is to define what every candidate receives at each stage, regardless of which recruiter is handling them.
Get ten minutes with the people who set priorities
Jennifer McClure's advice is deliberately small: arrange a short meeting with your organisation's leadership. Ten minutes with department heads or the highest-level managers available can give you a clear view of how your team and its work are actually perceived.
She acknowledges that access gets harder as organisations grow, and that a very large employer makes direct contact with senior leaders difficult. The principle still holds: find the shortest route to someone who can tell you what the business is prioritising, and use the time to ask rather than to report.
Her related point is about role. A recruiter who only records what leadership says stays a note-taker. The value comes from turning that insight into a change in how you market roles, approach candidates or brief clients.
A checklist for choosing where to start
Use these signals to pick one practice for the next quarter rather than all six.
- If job descriptions read as lists of technologies and interviews feel like skill quizzes, start with performance-based hiring.
- If leaders receive reports but do not act on them, or dispute the numbers, the gap is the data wonk role.
- If your dashboards show activity counts but you cannot say where candidates drop out, start with funnel ratios.
- If a recent disruption left people uncertain about how decisions are made, start with the trust definition.
- If candidate feedback varies by which recruiter handled the case, start with candidate experience design.
- If your team cannot state the business's top hiring priority, start with the ten-minute leadership conversation.
For each practice, record three things: the decision it informs, the person accountable for it, and the evidence you will look at in ninety days. That record is what separates an adopted practice from a good intention.
Frequently asked questions
What is performance-based hiring in practice?
It means defining the role by the results the hire must deliver and interviewing for evidence of comparable results, rather than screening on a list of skills. A useful opening question is to ask the candidate which single project or task they consider the most significant accomplishment of their career so far, then spend the rest of the interview on how it was delivered and what obstacles were involved.
How is a data wonk different from a reporting analyst?
A reporting analyst extracts numbers from your systems and presents them. A data wonk also tests whether those numbers are valid, looks for predictive signals and challenges assumptions the team has stopped examining. The difference is between supplying reports and making data usable for decisions.
Which recruiting metrics should replace vanity metrics?
Stage-to-stage ratios in the hiring funnel. Compare sourcing strategy against phone screening, and screening against whether an offer was extended and accepted. These ratios show where candidates are lost, which is more actionable than counts of activity.
Why does candidate experience matter if the candidate is not hired?
Because treatment during the process affects what candidates say about your agency afterwards. A positive experience can generate better word of mouth, which supports the agency's brand even when a particular application does not lead to a placement.