The trusted advisor formula: how top recruiters win and keep more clients and candidates
This on-demand panel brings together five recruiting leaders to explain how a recruiter stops being a replaceable order-taker and becomes the advisor clients and senior candidates call first.
The session covers the mindset shift, the positioning frameworks, the conversation habits that build long-term loyalty, and the tactics behind repeat business and referrals. It is aimed at agency owners, executive search professionals, and recruiters weighing a move from contingent to retained work.
What the panel covers
The session is built on one claim: recruiters who only fill orders get swapped out, while those who advise get kept on. The speakers work through five threads:
- Rethinking your role so you are a partner in the hiring decision, not a supplier waiting for instructions.
- Ways to make your contribution hard to replace, so clients see you as part of their planning.
- Conversation habits that turn a single placement into a lasting relationship.
- The moves that bring clients back and prompt them to recommend you.
- Case material from recruiters who have already made the shift.
The live session has passed; the recording is available to watch on demand.
Is this panel right for you?
Use this quick check before you press play:
- You take briefs and fill roles, but clients rarely ask your opinion beyond the shortlist.
- You want to move from contingent placements toward retained search or advisory work.
- You are an agency owner building recurring revenue and sales systems.
- You want better conversations with senior candidates, not just faster submissions.
- You are curious how experienced recruiters describe the shift from transaction to partnership.
If two or more of those apply, the panel is likely a good fit. If you only need a sourcing tool walkthrough, this is not that session.
Order-taker versus trusted advisor: a working distinction
The panel's central contrast is easy to state and harder to practise. An order-taker waits for a brief, fills it, and disappears until the next one. A trusted advisor is consulted before the brief exists, shapes what the role should be, and stays involved after the placement.
The practical test is who initiates the conversation. If the client only calls when a role is open, you are in the order-taking position. If the client calls to ask what the market looks like before they decide to hire, you have moved into the advisory position. The panel's frameworks are aimed at making that second situation routine rather than lucky.
A worked example: journey matching instead of title matching
One speaker describes her approach as journey matching rather than title matching. In practice, that changes the brief. A title-matching brief asks for a Chief Information Officer with fifteen years in financial services. A journey-matching brief asks where the candidate has been, what they have built, and what they want next, then checks whether that arc fits the client's next two years.
For a recruiter, the difference shows up in the first conversation. Instead of confirming the job description, you ask the hiring manager what the person in this seat needs to have done before, and what success looks like eighteen months in. That question is the beginning of advisory work, and it is also what makes a shortlist feel different from a keyword search.
Meet the panel
Five recruiting leaders join the discussion, each with a different route into advisory work.
- Diane Prince, founder of DianePrince.co, sold her previous company for $28 million and has completed multiple successful exits ranging from $20M to $50M. She helps agency owners build recurring revenue and sales systems that attract ideal clients and top candidates through consultative selling, positioning themselves as indispensable strategic partners and trusted career advisors.
- Debi Easterday, CEO of H2B Consulting, has 25 years of recruiting experience across technology, life sciences, and healthcare. She created H2B to move recruitment away from transactional practice toward a consultative, relationship-first model. Her stated principle: there is a human being at the end of every transaction, and treating recruitment as a partnership rather than just a placement produces better results for everyone involved.
- Mel Kelly, founder of MK Talent Advisory and former Senior Talent Acquisition Lead at PwC UK, has 15 years of experience. The MK IMPACT Talent Framework™ grew out of a pattern she kept seeing: hiring treated as an afterthought, and businesses paying for it. Her FTSE 100 client work, in her account, shows that advising both clients and candidates replaces constant firefighting with hiring that is confident and can scale.
- Somer Hackley, founder of Distinguished Search and author of *Search in Plain Sight: Demystifying Executive Search*, specializes in executive-level technology, product, and security placements. She works with a network of 1,800+ CIO/CTOs and has speaking experience at Harvard, Stanford, and Kellogg Northwestern. Her approach is journey matching, not title matching; she built Distinguished Search to prioritize long-term partnerships over transactional wins, on the view that relationships and reputation drive sustainable recruiting success.
- Louise Archer, founder of Retrained Search, has helped 400+ recruitment founders globally transition from contingent to retained search. She created the Search Foundations and Search Mastery programs, which teach recruiters how to win high-value retained work and build predictable growth engines. Her stated principle: the industry needed a clear pathway from transaction-hunting to true advisory work, and her frameworks are meant to help recruiters shift their identity from order-taker to strategic partner, command higher fees, and build stronger client relationships.
Follower counts and profile links shown on the event page are as published there and change over time.
Watch the recording
The full panel discussion is available on demand. The recording sits on the event page alongside the speaker profiles, so you can watch the session and follow up with individual speakers afterwards.
Frequently asked questions
Is this a live event or a recording?
It is an on-demand webinar. The live session has already taken place, and the recording is available to watch now.
Who is the panel aimed at?
Recruiters and agency owners who want to move beyond transactional placements toward advisory relationships with clients and senior candidates. It is especially relevant to anyone considering a shift from contingent to retained search.
What topics does the session cover?
The mindset shift from order-taker to strategic partner, positioning frameworks, conversation habits that build loyalty, tactics for repeat clients and referrals, and real examples from recruiters who changed their results.
Who are the speakers?
Diane Prince, Debi Easterday, Mel Kelly, Somer Hackley, and Louise Archer. Their backgrounds span agency ownership, executive search, talent advisory, and retained-search coaching.