Skip to content

Recruitment Advice from Experts: Five Questions, Practical Answers

Recruiting is a craft built on judgment, relationships and follow-through.

This guide gathers the themes that came up when a group of recruiters were asked five direct questions about their work, then turns those themes into a checklist you can apply to your own desk. The aim is not to repeat slogans but to show what each answer looks like in practice.

What recruiters would choose as a superpower

When asked which single ability would most improve their work, most of the recruiters in the discussion picked mind-reading. Three of the five leaders named in the conversation chose it, including Aaron Gonsalves, Faye Spruce and Donna Levan. A smaller group, including Richard Halls and Ellie Dailey, preferred the ability to see the future.

Both wishes point at the same pressure: uncertainty about what a candidate is really thinking and what a client will really do. You cannot read minds, but you can reduce the guesswork. Structured check-ins, written summaries after each call and clear next-step confirmations give you a version of foresight that is actually available.

Advice for recruiters who are just starting

The answers here differed, which is useful in itself. Donna Levan framed the work as a long game and urged persistence. Another guest advised newcomers to behave like a sponge and absorb as much information as possible. Others emphasised building relationships, understanding the market and asking for help whenever you feel lost.

Put together, that is a simple early-career routine: keep going after slow weeks, keep learning about roles and sectors, keep investing in relationships, and keep asking questions rather than guessing. None of these require special talent, only consistency.

The heart of the candidate experience

Asked what matters most for candidates, the recruiters converged on clear communication and transparency. Aaron Gonsalves added a stronger point: the candidate should be treated with respect at every stage of the process.

Respect is easy to claim and harder to demonstrate. It shows up in timely updates, honest feedback, realistic timelines and a willingness to say when a role is no longer moving forward. A useful test is to read your last five candidate messages and ask whether each one would feel respectful if you were the recipient.

The tools recruiters reach for most

LinkedIn topped the list of tools the group discussed, which is not surprising given its professional network and detailed profiles. It remains a common starting point for sourcing and for making contact with potential candidates. Beyond that, the recruiters stressed the importance of a strong applicant tracking system as a core part of the stack.

The practical lesson is not to collect tools but to connect them. A sourcing channel is more useful when candidate details flow into a system that tracks conversations, stages and follow-ups, so nothing depends on memory.

What makes an ideal recruiter

The answers varied, but three themes stood out. Empathy came first: the ability to see a situation from both the candidate's and the employer's side, including their needs, fears and hopes. Strong communication came next, covering role explanations, feedback and offer conversations. Finally, the recruiters pointed to the human side of hiring, where a placement changes someone's life and should be handled fairly, openly and with respect.

A short self-check follows from this. Before a difficult call, ask: have I understood both sides, can I explain the situation clearly, and am I treating the person as more than a vacancy to fill?

A weekly checklist drawn from these answers

  1. Reduce guesswork: send a written summary after every candidate and client call.
  2. Play the long game: follow up on slow opportunities instead of dropping them.
  3. Keep learning: block time each week to study a role, sector or client you do not fully understand.
  4. Ask when unsure: flag gaps early rather than improvising an answer.
  5. Protect respect: review your candidate messages for tone, clarity and timeliness.
  6. Connect your tools: make sure sourcing activity lands in your tracking system with a next step attached.
  7. Practise empathy: restate the candidate's and the client's priorities before advising either side.

Frequently asked questions

What is one superpower recruiters wish they had?

Most of the recruiters in the discussion chose mind-reading, with three of the five named leaders picking it. A smaller group preferred the ability to see the future. Both wishes reflect the uncertainty of hiring, which structured check-ins and written summaries can partly reduce.

What is your advice for new recruiters?

The advice ranged from persistence and playing the long game to absorbing as much information as possible. Others emphasised building relationships, understanding the market and asking for help whenever you feel lost.

What is the most important thing about the candidate experience?

Clear communication and transparency were the shared themes. Aaron Gonsalves added that candidates should be treated with respect throughout the entire process.

Which are your most used recruitment tools?

LinkedIn was named most often, valued for its professional network and detailed profiles. A strong applicant tracking system was also described as a top priority.

How can a recruiter show respect during a rejection?

Give a timely, specific reason where possible, avoid vague holding messages, and confirm the outcome in writing. Respect is judged by how the least welcome news is delivered, not only by the successful placements.