Skip to content

Five pre-interview moves that protect a placement

A recruiter cannot sit the interview, but most of what decides the outcome happens before it starts.

Late arrivals, candidates who do not know the role, vague hiring-manager expectations and quiet doubts about the job all surface at the worst possible moment. The five moves below are small, repeatable and can be run for every candidate on your desk.

Why the hour before the interview matters more than the hour after

The interview is the point where your work becomes visible, and it is also the point where you have the least control. What you can control is the preparation: whether the candidate arrives, whether they understand the company and the role, whether the hiring manager and you agree on the bar, whether the candidate actually wants the job, and whether the hiring manager walks in already knowing the candidate's strengths. Treat these as five separate checks rather than one vague 'prep' task, because each fails in a different way and needs a different fix.

The five checks, in the order they usually fail

Run these in sequence. Each one catches a problem the next one cannot.

  1. Attendance. Confirm the candidate will actually be there. A short call a couple of hours before the interview is the simplest nudge, and it catches the candidate who has forgotten, double-booked or gone quiet.
  1. Briefing. A day before, send the candidate the material they need: what the company does, what the role involves and who they are meeting. A candidate who cannot explain the role they are interviewing for undermines both of you.
  1. Hiring-manager alignment. Ask the hiring manager to describe the minimum acceptable profile, not an idealised one. Expectations have to be set before you shortlist, and the budget has to match the seniority you are asking for.
  1. Candidate motivation. Find out whether the candidate genuinely wants this job. A candidate who is selected and then declines costs more time than one who is screened out early.
  1. Personal note to the hiring manager. Before the interview, send a short message naming the candidate's strengths and why they fit. It gives the interviewer a frame and shows you have done the work.

A simple timing plan

The five checks do not all happen at the same moment. A workable rhythm looks like this:

  • When the role opens: agree the minimum bar and the budget with the hiring manager (check 3).
  • When the candidate is confirmed for interview: ask what they want from the move and why this role (check 4).
  • The day before: send the company and role briefing (check 2).
  • The day before or the morning of: send the personal note to the hiring manager (check 5).
  • A couple of hours before: call the candidate to confirm they are going (check 1).

If you only have time for two, do the attendance call and the hiring-manager alignment. Those two prevent the most visible failures.

Worked example: one senior role, five checks

Suppose you are filling a senior operations role. The hiring manager initially describes a candidate with twenty years of relevant experience at a salary well below the market for that profile. Check 3 catches the mismatch before you shortlist, and you agree a realistic bar and budget instead.

You then speak to a shortlisted candidate. They are interested but vague about why they would move. Check 4 turns that into a real conversation about scope and reporting line, and you learn the role is a step down in title but a step up in ownership. That is useful information for the hiring manager, not a reason to drop the candidate.

The day before, you send the briefing (check 2). The morning of, you send the personal note naming the candidate's ownership experience (check 5). Two hours before, you call to confirm (check 1). If the candidate had gone quiet at that call, you would have had time to warn the hiring manager rather than leave them waiting.

Three different failures, three different fixes

It helps to separate the ways a pre-interview plan breaks down, because they are often lumped together as 'the candidate let us down'.

  • No-show or late arrival. The candidate did not turn up or arrived late. The fix is the confirmation call and a clear point of contact.
  • Unprepared candidate. The candidate turned up but could not speak about the company or the role. The fix is the day-before briefing.
  • Declined offer after selection. The candidate interviewed well and was selected, then chose not to join. The fix is the earlier motivation conversation, not a harder sell at offer stage.

Each of these is preventable at a different point in the process, which is why the five checks are worth running as a sequence rather than as a single reminder.

What to record against each candidate

If you keep a short record for each interview, the five checks become auditable rather than remembered. Useful fields:

  • Interview date and time, plus the confirmation call outcome.
  • Briefing sent (yes/no) and the date it went out.
  • Hiring-manager minimum bar and budget, agreed before shortlisting.
  • Candidate motivation notes: why this role, why now, what would make them decline.
  • Personal note sent to the hiring manager (yes/no).
  • Outcome: attended, late, no-show, declined after offer.

Recording the outcome alongside the checks lets you see which step is failing most often in your own desk, rather than guessing.

Frequently asked questions

Is a confirmation call before the interview too intrusive?

It is a short logistics call, not a second interview. Its purpose is to confirm the candidate is still attending and has the right time, place or link. Candidates generally treat it as a sign the recruiter is organised.

What should the day-before briefing include?

At minimum: what the company does, what the role involves and who the candidate is meeting. The point is that the candidate can speak accurately about the opportunity, not that they have memorised a company history.

How do I get a hiring manager to state a realistic bar?

Ask for the minimum acceptable profile and the budget separately, and write both down before you shortlist. If the two do not match, raise it then rather than after the interview.

When should I check whether the candidate really wants the job?

Before the interview, not at offer stage. A short conversation about why they would move and what would make them decline is enough to surface most doubts while there is still time to act on them.

What goes in the personal note to the hiring manager?

A few lines naming the candidate's specific strengths and why they fit this role. It gives the interviewer a frame for the conversation and shows the shortlist was considered rather than forwarded.