Skip to content

Reference Checks: A Practical Guide to Questions, Steps and Types

A reference check is a structured conversation with someone who has worked closely with a candidate — a former supervisor, a colleague or a client — to learn how that person actually performed.

It is not a formality. Done well, it confirms claims made in the interview and on the resume, surfaces patterns a single conversation cannot, and gives the hiring team a second, independent view before an offer is signed. Done badly, it becomes a box-ticking exercise that adds no signal. This guide covers the benefits, a repeatable ten-step process, the six main reference types, and the questions that produce usable answers.

What a reference check actually verifies

The referee is someone with direct knowledge of the candidate's work — typically a former manager, a teammate or a client. The purpose is threefold: confirm the information the candidate supplied, validate qualifications and experience, and gather insight into work-related skills and attributes. Because the referee saw the candidate in a real working context, their answers can corroborate or contradict what the interview and resume suggested. That is the whole point: an independent data point, not a repeat of the candidate's own narrative.

Five reasons reference checks earn their place in the process

  1. They verify qualifications and experience beyond what the interview or resume showed — including performance metrics and employment duration. 2. They test culture fit: work history, communication style and ability to collaborate all surface in a referee's account. 3. They confirm work ethic and performance, including reliability, deadline behaviour and how the candidate handled challenges. 4. They identify strengths and development areas with concrete examples — problem-solving, leadership, and where extra support might be needed. 5. They mitigate hiring risk by catching warning signs that slipped past the interview, lowering the chance of a costly mis-hire.

Three preparation steps before you pick up the phone

First, decide who. The most useful referees are people who shared a workspace with the candidate — supervisors, teammates or clients from previous roles. A name on a list is not enough; the referee needs direct exposure to the candidate's work. Second, decide how to reach them. Get current phone numbers and email addresses, and prefer professional contacts over personal ones, because professional referees have seen the candidate operate in a work environment. Third, brief the candidate. Explain why the check is happening and how it will run, stress that honest feedback matters, and reassure them that what is shared will be handled confidentially. A candidate who understands the process is less anxious and the conversation runs more smoothly.

A ten-step reference check process

  1. Build the referee list and confirm each contact detail is current and accurate. 2. Set expectations with the candidate: explain the rationale, the value of honest feedback and the confidentiality of the process. 3. Choose the channel. Phone calls allow follow-up questions and a more interactive discussion; email is a workable alternative for gathering written feedback. 4. Build rapport: introduce yourself, explain your role, thank the referee for their time, and keep the tone comfortable so candid answers are more likely. 5. Prepare targeted, open-ended questions covering background, skills, work ethic, performance and overall recommendation. 6. Listen actively and take detailed notes — key points, memorable examples, strengths and any concerns — so you can compare feedback later. 7. Protect confidentiality: tell referees their feedback will be handled with discretion and used only to assess suitability, and do not share it with unauthorised people. 8. Stay within the law and ethical guidelines for your jurisdiction on reference checks, privacy and discrimination, and treat every candidate equally. 9. Analyse the notes for patterns, strengths, weaknesses and overall impressions; consistency across referees is what validates the candidate's claims. 10. Share the findings with the hiring team so the final decision draws on more than one perspective.

Six types of reference and what each one is good for

Employment references come from former employers and speak to job title, performance, work ethic and suitability. Character references come from personal or professional acquaintances who can vouch for skills, integrity and personal qualities, offering a broader view of personality and interpersonal style. Academic references suit recent graduates or candidates with limited work history; professors, mentors or advisors can speak to academic achievement, research skills and professional potential. Professional references are people who worked closely with the candidate but were not direct supervisors, adding perspective on work style and collaboration. Managerial references come from former supervisors or managers and are the strongest source on leadership, decision-making and managerial potential. Peer references come from colleagues who worked alongside the candidate and are best for teamwork, flexibility and day-to-day collaboration.

Where an applicant tracking system helps

An ATS can automate the generation and sending of reference requests so they go out consistently and promptly, saving manual effort. It centralises responses in one place, so nothing is overlooked and reminders are easy to send. It stores reference records securely, which supports data-protection obligations — particularly relevant in regulated sectors such as healthcare and finance. And it supports analysis and reporting, so patterns across candidates can inform decisions rather than sitting in scattered notes.

Worked example: reconciling conflicting feedback

Suppose a candidate for a team-lead role lists a former manager and a peer. The manager says the candidate delivered projects on time but was slow to escalate risks. The peer says the candidate was the person everyone went to when a deadline slipped. Read separately, those answers look contradictory. Read together, they describe someone who absorbs pressure personally rather than raising it upward — a strength in peer relationships and a risk in a leadership role. The next step is not to discard either answer but to ask a follow-up of a third referee: how did the candidate handle a project that was going off track? The pattern across referees, not any single quote, is what should shape the hiring conversation.

Reference check vs background check: a failure distinction

These are different tools and they fail in different ways. A reference check gathers subjective opinion from people who worked with the candidate — useful for judging performance and fit, but vulnerable to a referee who is too generous, too distant from the candidate's day-to-day work, or simply unavailable. A background check verifies factual history — employment, education, criminal records, credit history — and fails when records are incomplete or the scope is wrong for the role. Relying on references to confirm facts, or on a background check to judge fit, is the classic mistake. Use references for judgement and background checks for verification.

A short pre-call checklist

Before each reference call, confirm: the referee has direct knowledge of the candidate's work; contact details are current; the candidate has been briefed on the process and confidentiality; your questions are open-ended and role-relevant; you have a place to record notes that only authorised people can access; and you know which jurisdiction's rules on privacy and discrimination apply. If any of those is missing, fix it before dialling.

Frequently asked questions

What are some common reference check questions?

Interviewers typically use open-ended questions so referees can give detailed answers. Useful examples include: how would you describe the employee's performance during their time with your organisation; can you give specific examples of the candidate's achievements or contributions; what were the candidate's major strengths and areas for improvement in their previous role; and what were their significant accomplishments in their previous position. Open-ended phrasing lets the referee share their own experience, which produces richer insight than yes/no answers.

What is the difference between a reference check and a background check?

A reference check involves contacting people who worked directly with the candidate to gather insight into performance and suitability for a specific role. A background check verifies personal and professional history — employment history, educational qualifications, criminal records and credit history. In short, reference checks produce subjective feedback from people who interacted with the candidate; background checks validate factual information.

How many reference checks should be conducted?

It is common for employers to conduct at least two to three reference checks, which gives multiple perspectives on the candidate's abilities and work performance. Multiple referees allow a more comprehensive assessment and help validate the information the candidate provided.

Should I use phone or email for reference checks?

Phone calls allow a more interactive discussion and the chance to ask follow-up questions, which often produces richer detail. Email can serve as an alternative for gathering written feedback, particularly when a referee is hard to reach by phone. Many teams use phone for the primary conversation and email for confirmation or scheduling.

What should I do if referees give conflicting answers?

Look for the pattern rather than treating any single answer as decisive. Consistency across referees tends to validate the candidate's claims; a specific contradiction is worth a targeted follow-up with another referee. The goal is to understand the candidate's behaviour in context, not to score each answer in isolation.