Recruitment tips: five steps to honest, faster placements
Recruiters sit between two parties who rarely share the same information: the candidate and the employer.
The work goes better when both sides hear the same honest version of events, early and often. The five steps below come from seasoned recruiter Faye Spruce, who set them out on an episode of The Recruitment Scoop as her approach to using authentic communication with candidates. They turn that principle into daily habits — how you open an interview, how you read a CV, how you make a first call, how you shorten a slow process and how you keep people informed when there is no news.
Step 1: Make the interview a two-way conversation
An interview is usually treated as a test the candidate has to pass. Faye Spruce's first step flips that: treat it as the point where both sides find out whether the fit is real. That means the recruiter also answers questions, explains what happens next and is candid about the role's weak spots as well as its strengths.
What good looks like:
- The candidate leaves knowing the next step and the timeline.
- You can describe the candidate's motivation in your own words, not just their job history.
- You have told the candidate at least one honest thing about the role that is not in the job ad.
Step 2: Read the CV for achievements, then watch for signals
A CV that lists duties tells you what a person was asked to do. A CV that lists outcomes tells you what they actually changed. Prefer the second kind: it suggests ownership rather than attendance.
Beyond the document, response behaviour is a useful signal. A candidate who replies promptly, asks informed questions and turns up prepared is showing real interest. A candidate who goes quiet, shows little curiosity about the role or arrives unprepared is showing something else — though not always the same thing. Slow replies can mean a competing offer, a busy week or a lost message. The distinction matters:
- Slow but engaged: replies late, yet answers fully and asks follow-up questions. Worth a direct check-in.
- Slow and disengaged: replies late with one-line answers and no questions. Treat as a lower priority.
- Unprepared: has not read the brief or cannot explain why the role interests them. Ask once, then judge.
Step 3: Balance the cold call between friendly and professional
A cold call fails when it sounds like a sales pitch and succeeds when it sounds like a person offering a specific opportunity. Faye Spruce's advice is to keep a friendly but professional tone and to establish the candidate's availability before raising the reason for the call. The practical fix is sequencing.
A simple opening that follows that order:
- Name yourself and your firm in one sentence.
- Ask whether now is a good moment for a two-minute conversation.
- If yes, give one line on the role and one line on why you thought of them.
- If no, agree a specific time to call back.
Leading with the pitch before checking availability is what makes a recruiter sound like a salesperson. Checking first costs ten seconds and changes how the rest of the call lands.
Step 4: Shorten the relay between candidate and client
Placements stall when the interview chain is longer than the candidate's patience. Two pieces of information let you fix that: when the candidate is available, and what the employer's process actually involves. Faye Spruce points out that holding both lets a recruiter navigate the process more effectively and even suggest streamlining measures to the client.
With both in hand you can suggest a leaner sequence — fewer rounds, grouped interviews, a decision date agreed up front. Candidates notice when a process respects their time, and a shorter process usually produces a faster decision.
A quick check before you hand a candidate to a client:
- Do you know the candidate's notice period and available interview slots?
- Do you know how many stages the client plans and who decides at each one?
- Have you proposed any reduction in stages, and recorded the client's answer?
Step 5: Keep candidates informed even when nothing has changed
Silence is the most common complaint candidates have about recruiters, and it usually comes from a well-meant wish to wait until there is something to report. Faye Spruce's final step argues the opposite: even with no new developments, keeping candidates informed makes a real difference. That instinct to stay quiet backfires. A short update that says 'no decision yet, expected Thursday' preserves trust better than two weeks of quiet.
Set expectations at the start: how many stages, who interviews, roughly when each decision lands. Then keep to that rhythm, and say so when a date slips.
Tracking each step in your ATS
The five steps only hold if the information behind them is recorded somewhere the whole team can see. A simple field map:
- Interview stage: next step and agreed date, visible on the candidate record.
- CV review: a short note on achievements found, not a copy of the CV.
- Response signal: last contact date and whether the candidate asked questions.
- Availability: notice period and interview slots, kept current.
- Client process: number of stages and decision owner, agreed in writing.
- Update cadence: date of last candidate update and date of next promised update.
Frequently asked questions
What is the single most important recruitment habit in this guide?
Telling candidates what is actually happening. Every other step — the interview, the CV read, the call, the shortened process — depends on the candidate trusting what you say next.
How do I tell a slow candidate apart from an uninterested one?
Look at the quality of the reply, not just the speed. A late reply that answers fully and asks questions suggests a busy but engaged candidate. A late reply with one-line answers and no curiosity suggests lower interest. Ask once before deciding.
Should I pitch the role at the start of a cold call?
No. Confirm the candidate has a moment to talk first, then give a one-line summary of the role and why you called them. Pitching before checking availability is what makes a recruiter sound like a salesperson.
What should I do when a client's hiring process is slow?
Ask the client for the number of stages and the decision owner, then propose a shorter sequence — fewer rounds, grouped interviews, an agreed decision date. Record what the client agreed to so the candidate hears the same version.