What Separates Top-Billing Recruiters: Three Behaviors to Build
Recruiters who consistently bill well are rarely separated from their peers by a single tactic.
In the second episode of The Recruitment Podcast, hosted by Kate O’Neill and featuring Lysha Holmes of Qui Recruitment, three behaviors come up as the ones that compound over time: a genuine appetite to learn, disciplined consistency with every step of the process, and empathy that cannot be faked. This guide restates those behaviors as observable practices, adds a short self-check, and shows how a single skipped step can turn a placement into a transactional exchange.
Why behavior beats transaction
A transactional recruiter forwards a CV without explaining what makes the candidate strong or what the candidate actually wants from their next move. The exchange is surface-level and impersonal. Relationship-led recruiting looks different: the recruiter listens actively, understands the candidate's situation, and can speak to both strengths and aspirations. Lysha Holmes frames this bluntly — if you are not in the industry to build genuine relationships, there may not be a long-term place for you in it. That is not a moral judgment so much as a durability point: relationships survive a single placement and generate the next one.
1. Curiosity to learn and develop
The first behavior is a real appetite for learning and growth. Holmes pushes back on fixating on graduates: many capable people cannot afford higher education or choose not to take on that financial burden, and a degree does not guarantee top billing. What predicts performance better is a commitment to self-improvement, adaptability, and a hunger for knowledge. In practice, that looks like asking better questions after a lost placement, seeking feedback on client calls, and treating each search as a chance to sharpen judgment rather than repeat a script.
2. Consistency is non-negotiable
The second behavior is following every step of the process, every time. Holmes's instruction is direct: never cut corners. Each detail matters — understanding what a candidate needs, keeping client communication clear, confirming signed terms, and having a shared understanding of the process. Skipping a step now tends to surface as a breakdown later. Her analogy makes the point: a placement can have the candidate ready, the terms signed, and the process clear, yet one omitted step leaves the whole arrangement unstable. Consistency is what keeps the structure intact, whether the task is large or small.
3. Empathy will make you stand out
The third behavior is empathy, which Holmes treats as an innate skill rather than a technique to be taught or faked. People remember how you made them feel. Empathy shows up when you invest in the full story of the people you work with — their challenges, their goals, and sometimes what is happening in their personal lives. That does not mean overstepping; it means listening closely enough that your recommendations reflect the person, not just the CV.
Worked example: the skipped step
Imagine a recruiter who has a strong candidate, signed terms with the client, and a clear process. They send the CV across without explaining the candidate's unique strengths or what the candidate wants next. The client sees a document, not a person; the candidate feels handled, not represented. Nothing technically failed, but the exchange was transactional. Now replay it with the missing ingredient: a short note to the client on why this candidate fits, and a conversation with the candidate about their goals before submission. Same placement, different relationship — and a much better chance of the next one.
Not yet skilled vs. transactional
It helps to separate two failure modes. A recruiter who is still learning may miss a step because they lack a checklist or feedback; that is a skill gap and it is fixable with practice. A transactional recruiter treats the exchange as a transaction by default — forwarding without context, skipping the conversation about aspirations, or treating the client as a destination rather than a relationship. The first needs training; the second needs a change in approach. Holmes's three behaviors map neatly onto that distinction: curiosity addresses the skill gap, consistency addresses the process gap, and empathy addresses the relational gap.
About the episode
This is the second episode of The Recruitment Podcast, hosted by Kate O’Neill. Lysha Holmes is Founder and Managing Director of Qui Recruitment. Kate O’Neill is Recruitment Director at Kate O’Neill Recruitment Solutions. The episode covers why empathy is a recruiter's advantage and how consistency defines success.
| Behavior | Observable signal | Common failure mode | Quick action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Curiosity to learn and develop | You seek feedback after a lost placement and adjust your approach | Repeating the same script without reviewing outcomes | Book one feedback conversation this week |
| Consistency is non-negotiable | Every step is completed: candidate needs, client communication, signed terms, shared process | Skipping a step to save time, then fixing the fallout later | Run a five-minute pre-submission checklist |
| Empathy will make you stand out | You can describe the candidate's challenges and goals, not just their skills | Forwarding a CV without context or a conversation | Add a two-line candidate context note before sending |
This checklist is an editorial aid based on the three behaviors discussed in the episode; it is not a validated assessment instrument.
Frequently asked questions
What are the three behaviors of top-billing recruiters?
Curiosity to learn and develop, consistency with every step of the process, and empathy that cannot be faked. Holmes presents them as compounding behaviors rather than one-off tactics.
Does a degree predict recruiter performance?
Not reliably. Holmes argues that a degree does not guarantee top billing and that many capable people either cannot afford higher education or choose not to take on that financial burden. Commitment to self-improvement, adaptability, and a hunger for knowledge matter more.
Can empathy be taught?
Holmes treats empathy as an innate skill rather than something you can fake or teach. It shows up when you genuinely invest in understanding the people you work with — their challenges, goals, and sometimes their personal circumstances.
What does a transactional recruiter look like?
A transactional recruiter forwards a CV without understanding or communicating the candidate's unique strengths or career aspirations. The exchange is surface-level and lacks depth or personalization.