How to Lead in Recruitment: Five Behaviours That Build Stronger Teams
Recruitment leadership is not only about hitting targets.
A team that feels understood, safe to contribute and clear on its goals is better placed to handle pressure and change. This guide sets out five behaviours that support that kind of team, with a checklist for putting each one into practice.
1. Treat empathy as a strategy, not a soft extra
Empathy is often filed under 'people skills' and left there. In practice it is a working method: you find out what is actually blocking someone, then adjust the work around it. A recruiter who is quietly drowning in admin will not be rescued by a motivational speech; they need the admin reduced or redistributed.
That is why empathy belongs in the same conversation as commercial targets. It tells you where the friction is, and friction is what eats margin. A leader who notices the friction early can fix it before it turns into a resignation.
Use this check:
- Ask each team member what is currently making their work harder.
- Separate workload problems from confidence problems.
- Respond with a concrete support step, not only encouragement.
- Review whether the support actually changed the situation.
2. Decide whether you want to lead before you manage
A strong personal billing record is one kind of evidence. It tells you that someone can run a desk. It says much less about whether they can build the conditions for six other people to run theirs. The skills overlap, but they are not the same skills, and treating one as proof of the other is how teams end up with a manager who is still, in their head, a biller.
Before accepting a management role, it is worth pausing on a simple question: do you want the work of supporting other people's performance, or do you want to keep producing your own? Both are legitimate answers. Neither is a promotion over the other.
A useful distinction: a top biller is measured mainly by personal output, while a leader is measured by the conditions that let other people produce. If the second kind of work does not appeal to you, management may be the wrong next step. Leadership also requires dedication to the team's well-being; without that, the working environment can become difficult.
3. Move from control to collaboration
The command-and-control model still shows up in recruitment teams, usually as an approval step on everything. It feels safe to the person holding the approval, and it slows everyone else down. The alternative is not an absence of standards; it is agreeing the boundaries up front and then letting people work inside them.
In the source conversation, Desiree Goldey argues that inclusive leadership leads to better productivity. The mechanism is psychological safety: people raise problems and ideas early because they are not afraid of being judged for it. Early problems are cheap to fix. Late problems are expensive.
Checklist for a collaboration shift:
- Replace 'approve every step' with 'agree the boundaries'.
- Ask for a dissenting view before closing a decision.
- Thank people for raising problems early.
- Review whether decisions are being made by the people closest to the work.
4. Align goals with empathy
A target without a route is just pressure. Team members need to know both what the number is for and how they are expected to reach it. When the goal and the steps are joined up, the week runs more smoothly; when they are not, people improvise and the results become unpredictable.
Goldey's point in the source is that goals work best when they align with actionable steps. Empathy is what lets a leader see the difference between a team that is working hard and a team that is working smart. If effort is high and output is flat, the goal or the route needs re-examining, not more effort.
A quick test: ask each person to explain the goal in their own words and name the next concrete step. If the answers diverge, the goal has not landed yet.
5. Build adaptability into how the team works
Recruitment changes constantly: client priorities shift, roles get pulled, channels that worked last quarter go quiet. A leader who cannot adjust to that will struggle, and Goldey is explicit in the source that flexibility is part of the job.
Adaptability is easier to sustain when the team knows what is fixed and what is flexible. Purpose and standards can stay stable while sourcing channels, priorities and weekly routines are reviewed. That gives people an anchor when circumstances move, rather than a sense that everything is up for grabs at once.
Quick reference: five behaviours and what to check
The table below is a reader checklist, not a scoring system. Use it to decide which behaviour needs attention first.
| Behaviour | What it looks like | Check question |
|---|---|---|
| Empathy as strategy | Listening to what the team needs and acting on it | What is making this person's work harder right now? |
| Leader before manager | Choosing leadership for the support role, not only the title | Am I willing to be measured by the team's conditions, not only my own output? |
| Collaboration over control | Open communication and psychological safety | Can someone disagree with me without fear of judgment? |
| Goals with empathy | Clear why and how behind each target | Can each person explain the goal and the next step? |
| Adaptability | Guiding the team through change | What stays fixed, and what are we willing to change? |
This checklist is an editorial aid based on the five behaviours discussed; it is not a validated assessment instrument.
Frequently asked questions
Is empathy really a leadership strategy in recruitment?
Yes. Empathy helps a leader understand what the team needs and where support is missing. It sits alongside commercial goals rather than replacing them, and it can improve how a team handles pressure.
Does being a top biller make someone a good recruitment leader?
Not automatically. Billing success and leadership call on different skills. Leadership involves supporting a team and understanding its needs, so it is worth reflecting on whether that work suits you before taking a management role.
What does psychological safety mean for a recruitment team?
It means team members can share ideas without fear of judgment. Leaders support it by inviting dissenting views, responding constructively to problems raised early and making clear where decisions are open to influence.
How do goals and empathy fit together?
Goals need a clear why and how. When leaders explain both and match targets with actionable steps, teams can work smart rather than only working hard. Empathy helps a leader notice when effort is rising without results.
Why is adaptability important in recruitment leadership?
The recruitment landscape keeps changing. Leaders need flexibility to guide a team through uncertainty and change while keeping it on track.