Rec-to-rec recruitment: trust, stigma and doing the homework
Rec-to-rec recruitment — placing recruiters into new recruitment jobs — has a reputation problem.
AJ Reid, co-founder of Equanimity Search, joined Kate O’Neill on The Recruitment Podcast to talk through the good, the bad and the ugly of the niche. This guide turns that conversation into a working checklist for anyone hiring or being hired inside the recruitment industry.
The good: relationships beat filling seats
When the market tightens, the recruiters who stand out are the ones who treat a placement as a match rather than a transaction. Reid’s point is that strong rec-to-rec work starts with asking better questions and putting in the extra effort to understand what both the candidate and the client actually need.
That means going beyond a job title and a salary band. A recruiter moving roles is weighing culture, desk structure, commission model, leadership style and long-term trajectory. A hiring firm is weighing billings history, market fit and how quickly someone can build a desk. The recruiter who maps both sides honestly is the one who gets repeat conversations.
The bad: a stigma that has to be earned back
Reid is direct about the trust barrier. Candidates and clients often open with a version of “we’ve had bad experiences with rec-to-rec before,” and that reaction is not irrational — it reflects real history in the niche.
Rebuilding trust is slow and unglamorous. It comes from doing what you said you would do, on the timeline you promised, and being clear about what you can and cannot influence. One good placement does not erase a bad first impression; a consistent pattern of follow-through does.
The ugly: outreach without research
The most common failure Reid describes is simple: recruiters reaching out without checking who they are contacting. A profile check takes seconds, yet it is skipped often enough to define the niche’s reputation.
He links this to how easy it is to enter recruitment and to gaps in training. When nobody teaches the basics of preparation, the shortcut becomes the default. The fix is not complicated — it is a habit.
A pre-outreach checklist for rec-to-rec recruiters
Use this before any first message to a candidate or client:
- Read the profile end to end, not just the headline. Note current firm, tenure and desk focus.
- Identify one specific reason this person is relevant to your role — and be able to say it in one sentence.
- Check whether your approach matches their actual specialism, not a nearby one.
- Decide what you are asking for: a conversation, a referral, or a firm “no.” Do not blur them.
- Write down what you will do next and when, so follow-through is a commitment rather than an intention.
- If you cannot answer “why this person, why now,” do not send the message.
What the difference looks like in practice
Two recruiters contact the same candidate about the same role.
The first sends a generic message: “Hi, I have an exciting opportunity that matches your profile — are you open to a chat?” The candidate has seen this before and does not reply.
The second opens with the candidate’s current desk and a specific reason the role fits: the firm’s market, the team structure and the fact that the candidate has been in the same seat for a stretch. The message asks one clear question and names a next step. The candidate replies, even if only to decline.
The difference is not charisma. It is the two seconds of research Reid points to, applied consistently.
Two different problems, two different fixes
It helps to separate the two issues the conversation raises, because they need different responses.
- Trust problem (stigma): the candidate or client has been burned before. The fix is consistency over time — promises kept, timelines met, no overselling.
- Competence problem (no research): the recruiter has not done the basic work. The fix is a process — a checklist, a training step, a review before sending.
Treating a trust problem as a competence problem leads to more polished messages that still feel hollow. Treating a competence problem as a trust problem leads to over-apologising instead of simply doing the work.
Hear the full conversation
AJ Reid is Director and Co-Founder of Equanimity Search. Kate O’Neill is a recruitment coach at Kate O’Neill Coaching. The conversation sits within The Recruitment Podcast series; where to listen is a detail to confirm with whoever maintains this page, so treat any episode link as unverified until it is checked.
Frequently asked questions
What is rec-to-rec recruitment?
It is recruitment aimed at recruiters — placing recruitment professionals into new roles inside agencies or in-house teams. Because both sides of the conversation are industry insiders, the niche carries its own expectations and its own reputation.
Why do candidates and clients distrust rec-to-rec recruiters?
Reid describes a common opening line from candidates and clients: they have had bad experiences with rec-to-rec before. The stigma is not abstract — it reflects real encounters with recruiters who overpromised or reached out without preparation.
How much research should a rec-to-rec recruiter do before reaching out?
At minimum, read the person’s profile and be able to state one specific reason they are relevant to the role. Reid’s point is that this takes seconds, so skipping it is a choice rather than a constraint.
Is the problem training or attitude?
Reid links the gap to the low barrier to entry in recruitment and to a lack of proper training. In practice it is both: a process that does not require preparation will produce unprepared outreach, and a culture that does not value preparation will not fix the process.