Skip to content

Purple squirrel candidates: should recruiters hire them?

Recruiters use the term purple squirrel for the candidate who seems to tick every box at once: the right skills, the right experience, the right attitude and the right salary expectations.

That combination is rare, and the people who match it are usually already employed and not looking. This guide separates the two candidate types, explains the trade-offs of chasing the rare hire, and gives you a checklist for deciding when a search is worth extending and when an available candidate plus development is the better bet.

What makes a purple squirrel candidate different?

A purple squirrel is the recruiter's shorthand for an almost ideal match: skills, experience, traits, qualifications and pay expectations all line up. The catch is availability. These candidates tend to be passive, already settled in a role, and unlikely to move unless something specific catches their interest. In a candidate-driven market that makes them genuinely scarce rather than merely hard to reach.

A normal squirrel, by contrast, is an active job seeker who meets the hiring criteria but does not bring an unusual extra. They are easier to find and quicker to engage. The trade-off is that they may need training and time to reach the level a purple squirrel would bring on day one. That is not a weakness to dismiss: with the right development, an average candidate can grow into the standout hire you were originally hunting for.

Purple squirrel vs normal squirrel at a glance

Use this comparison to frame the trade-off before you open a search. It is a decision aid, not a ranking: neither column is automatically the right answer.

A checklist for choosing your search strategy

Before committing to an extended purple squirrel hunt, answer these questions honestly:

  1. Can the role tolerate a longer time-to-fill? If the position must be covered quickly to meet basic requirements, an available candidate is usually the practical choice.
  2. Is the missing element trainable? If the gap is years of experience or a specific personality trait rather than a hard licence or certification, development may close it.
  3. Does the team need an immediate specialist, or can it absorb a learning curve? A role with no senior support around it raises the cost of training.
  4. Will a narrow search shrink your candidate pool? Restricting yourself to rare profiles can reduce diversity and exclude strong candidates you have not met yet.
  5. Does the candidate fit the culture, not just the CV? A perfect-on-paper profile can still lack the mindset or soft skills a team needs.
  6. What is your fallback if the purple squirrel never appears? Treat the rare hire as a bonus, not the only plan.

If most answers point toward speed, development capacity and culture fit, hire the available candidate and invest in them. If the role genuinely cannot be done without a rare, no-training specialist and you can afford the wait, keep the search open while you continue to review other applicants.

Why training and retention often beat the rare hire

When a company stops investing heavily in employee development, the appeal of a candidate who needs no training rises. But a fixed checklist of criteria is not automatically the best hire. People who lack the exact years or the polished profile can still adapt and grow, and that growth is linked to staying.

A dated external reference point: LinkedIn's workplace learning material reported that 94% of employees said they would stay longer at a company that invests in their learning. Treat that figure as a historical reference from the cited report rather than a current measurement, and check the latest edition before relying on it. The practical point stands: development can turn an ordinary hire into the kind of contributor you were searching for, and it can do so from inside the team.

Culture fit and the cost of a narrow search

A candidate can look flawless on paper and still be wrong for a particular team. Soft skills, attitude and cultural alignment matter as much as the qualifications column, and a rare profile does not guarantee any of them. Recruiters who fixate on the purple squirrel can also lose sight of other applicants with real potential.

Fair recruitment depends on equal opportunity and a broad pool. Chasing only the rarest profiles narrows that pool and can cost you the diversity benefits that come from considering a wider range of backgrounds. The safer approach is to keep the rare-hire search as one track and keep reviewing other candidates alongside it.

The verdict: keep the hunt, but do not depend on it

Both candidate types can be the right hire. The decision turns on your recruitment method and your client's needs. If you can absorb a longer process, a purple squirrel search is worth running. If you need to fill a role quickly against basic requirements, an available candidate is sufficient. Much of the time, finding a purple squirrel is a matter of luck, so it cannot be the only plan for filling a position.

The practical takeaway: run the rare-hire search in parallel with a normal pipeline, and do not overlook the candidate in front of you. With training and the right environment, that person may become the purple squirrel you were looking for.

Purple squirrel vs normal squirrel: decision comparison
DimensionPurple squirrelNormal squirrel
AvailabilityPassive; usually already employed and not actively lookingActive; readily available in the job market
Ease of findingRare and difficult to sourceEasier to find with a straightforward search
ProfileIdeal mix of skills, experience, traits, qualifications and salary expectationsMeets the hiring criteria but brings no unusual extra
Time to productivityExpected to need minimal training and guidanceMay need training and development to reach full potential
Search riskLonger process; outcome partly a matter of luckFaster fill; lower risk of an unfilled role
Diversity impactNarrow search can reduce pool diversityBroader pool supports equal opportunity and diversity
Best whenRole needs a rare specialist and time allowsRole must be filled quickly against basic requirements

Comparison reflects the editorial positions in the supplied article; it is not a measured ranking of candidate types.

Frequently asked questions

What is a purple squirrel candidate?

It is recruitment jargon for a candidate who appears to match a role on every dimension at once: skills, experience, traits, qualifications and salary expectations. The defining feature is rarity. Purple squirrels are usually passive, already established in a job, and unlikely to move unless something specific attracts them.

Should recruiters hire purple squirrels or normal candidates?

It depends on the role and the timeline. If the position needs a rare specialist and you can afford a longer search, pursue the purple squirrel while keeping other candidates in review. If you need to fill the role quickly against basic requirements, an available candidate is sufficient, especially when the missing element can be trained.

Can a normal candidate become a purple squirrel?

Yes. A candidate who meets the core criteria but lacks the exact years or polish can develop into the standout hire you wanted. Training supports adaptation and growth, and it is also linked to longer retention. That makes development a realistic alternative to an extended external search.

Does chasing purple squirrels hurt diversity?

It can. Restricting the search to a very rare profile narrows the candidate pool and can exclude people from a wider range of backgrounds. Fair recruitment depends on equal opportunity, so keep the rare-hire track but continue reviewing other applicants.