HR Hiring Tips: Emotional Intelligence, Humor and Better Interviews
Most hiring advice stops at 'read the resume carefully.' The harder skill is judging how a person will behave when a project slips, a colleague disagrees, or a client changes the brief mid-engagement.
This guide distills a conversation with HR commentator Suzanne Lucas, known online as the "Evil HR Lady," into six behaviors recruiters can apply in their next interview loop. The focus is on what you ask, what you listen for, and how you keep the process human while still making a defensible decision.
Who is Suzanne Lucas, the "Evil HR Lady"?
Suzanne Lucas began her career aiming at political science teaching, then moved into HR after discovering she enjoyed helping adults learn on the job. She started writing publicly in 2006 and picked a deliberately provocative pen name: the "Evil HR Lady." The joke plays on the unease people feel when HR appears in a meeting with leadership. In practice, the persona is a teaching device, not a warning. She has spent more than a decade writing and advising on staffing, and the advice below reflects that practitioner perspective rather than a formal research study.
Three ways to hire for emotional intelligence
Emotional intelligence (EI) is the capacity to notice and manage emotions in yourself and read them in others. In hiring, it predicts how someone will handle friction that no job description fully captures. Lucas treats it as a core screening dimension rather than a nice-to-have. The three practices below translate that into interview behavior.
1. Look past the resume
A strong CV shows what someone has done; it rarely shows how they behaved while doing it. Ask candidates to describe a specific interpersonal difficulty they navigated at work, then listen for what they noticed, what they chose to do, and what they would change. Lucas argues that predicting reactions in real situations matters more than the document itself. A useful follow-up is: 'What did the other person seem to need, and how did you find out?'
2. Screen for respect and maturity
Workplace conduct expectations have shifted: high performance no longer excuses inappropriate behavior. Build interview questions that surface how a candidate understands boundaries and treats people with less power than themselves. For example, ask how they handled a colleague who repeatedly interrupted them in meetings, or how they responded when a manager shared a confidential detail inappropriately. Prioritizing respect also improves the candidate experience, because people notice when an interview process takes their dignity seriously.
3. Redefine culture fit
Culture fit is often used as shorthand for 'someone like the hiring manager.' That narrows teams and hides bias. A better test is alignment with the company's stated values combined with perspectives the team does not already have. Before interviews, write down two or three values the role genuinely needs to exercise, then ask candidates for examples of how they have lived those values in a different environment. Look for both resonance and difference.
Why humor belongs in recruiting
Humor is not decoration. It changes how information is processed and remembered, and it helps recruiters recover from the inevitable mis-hire or rejected offer. Lucas frames it as a resilience practice: a way to keep learning when a decision goes wrong. Three reasons stand out.
Humor stimulates learning and creativity
A light touch lowers defensiveness and opens up problem-solving. When a candidate or hiring manager is stuck, a well-placed observation can reframe the conversation. Lucas puts it as a learning principle: if no one is laughing, the lesson is probably not landing. The practical takeaway is to keep interview language human and specific rather than scripted and formal.
Humor makes the message memorable
When you describe a role or a company with a little wit, the key points stick. That matters in candidate outreach, where attention is scarce and many messages sound identical. The goal is not to be funny for its own sake but to make the important details recognizable later, when the candidate is deciding between offers.
Humor helps you recover from bad hires
Every recruiter will make a wrong call at some point. The choice is whether to dwell on it or to extract the lesson and move on. Lucas borrows a principle from improv comedy: fail with joy. That does not mean ignoring the cost of a mis-hire; it means treating the setback as information rather than identity.
The core advice for newer recruiters
Being in HR does not automatically make someone an expert in it. Lucas's central recommendation is to recognize your own limits and ask the right questions at the right time. That means knowing when to consult a colleague, when to escalate, and when to admit that a situation is outside your experience. Continuous learning is the habit that turns a job title into a craft.
A five-step interview checklist
Use this sequence for any role where collaboration matters. It turns the six tips above into repeatable actions.
- Before the interview, write down two or three values the role must exercise and one interpersonal scenario the hire will likely face.
- Open with a behavioral question about a real disagreement or setback, not a hypothetical.
- Probe for what the candidate noticed about the other person, not only what they did.
- Ask one question about boundaries or respectful conduct, and listen for how they treat people with less power.
- Close by asking what they would do differently, and record the answer in the same fields for every candidate so comparisons are fair.
Worked example: reading a behavioral answer
Suppose a candidate is asked about a time a teammate missed a deadline. A weak answer describes the missed deadline and the candidate's heroic recovery. A stronger answer includes what the candidate noticed about the teammate's workload, how they raised the concern, and what they changed in the next sprint. The difference is not eloquence; it is whether the candidate can hold another person's perspective alongside their own. Score that dimension separately from technical skill so it does not get lost in the overall impression.
A useful distinction: 'not a fit' vs. 'different perspective'
When a hiring panel says a candidate is 'not a culture fit,' ask which value was actually missing. If the candidate shares the company's values but approaches the work differently, that is a perspective gap, not a values gap, and it may be exactly what the team needs. If the candidate's conduct conflicts with respect or boundaries, that is a values gap and should be treated as disqualifying regardless of technical strength. Naming the difference prevents culture fit from becoming a polite veto.
What to capture at each stage
A simple field map keeps interview evidence comparable across candidates.
- Screening call: motivation, notice period, and one example of handling ambiguity.
- Skills interview: technical evidence and one example of learning from a mistake.
- Values interview: one example of respectful disagreement and one example of working with someone unlike themselves.
- Debrief: a separate score for emotional intelligence, a note on which value was tested, and a one-line rationale for the final decision.
Frequently asked questions
Why does emotional intelligence matter more than a strong resume?
A resume shows what someone has done, but not how they will react when a project goes sideways or a colleague disagrees. Emotional intelligence predicts how a person will notice and manage those moments, which is why it belongs in the interview alongside technical evidence.
How do I tell culture fit apart from bias?
Name the specific value the role needs to exercise, then ask for an example of how the candidate has lived that value. If the candidate shares the value but approaches it differently, that is a perspective gap rather than a values gap. If the candidate's conduct conflicts with respect or boundaries, that is a values gap and should be treated as disqualifying.
Is humor appropriate in a formal hiring process?
Humor helps information stick and lowers defensiveness, but it should never come at a candidate's expense. Use it to make the role and the company recognizable, not to test whether someone laughs at your jokes.
What should a new recruiter do when they do not know the answer?
Say so and ask the right question of the right person. Recognizing your own limits and seeking advice early is a sign of competence, not a weakness, and it prevents small uncertainties from turning into costly mis-hires.