Skip to content

Recruitment strategies amid uncertainty: choosing a delivery model

When hiring budgets tighten, the question for agencies and in-house teams is rarely whether companies will keep hiring — they will — but which delivery model fits the client's situation.

Martin Dangerfield, CEO of immersive, traces how the recruitment model moved from pre-2008 transactional agency work, through the 2008 shift toward internal teams, to the post-COVID mix of embedded recruiters and agency-led RPO. This guide restates that evolution and adds a decision checklist for choosing between the three models.

The 2022 boom and the contraction that followed

In 2022, recruiters across in-house teams, agencies, and RPO providers were busy: many roles, quick turnaround, and accessible budgets. The market then contracted faster than many expected. Dangerfield notes that he initially read the slowdown as a summer lull. The longer view — from the 2008/09 recession and the 2000 dot-com bubble — is that economic crises are cyclical. Companies keep hiring through downturns and still need people who can engage candidates and move organizations forward. The practical question is not whether hiring stops, but which delivery model clients will pay for while budgets are tight.

The pre-2008 model: transactional agency work

Before 2008, the dominant pattern was straightforward: win a large client, stay in close contact, and work with them to define what they needed. Dangerfield observes that most agencies still operate this way today, delivering a similar transactional service across economic cycles. The model is simple and repeatable, but it depends on clients continuing to outsource the search rather than build internal capability.

The post-2008 shift: internal teams take the work in-house

The 2008 recession changed the pattern. Large organizations grew internal teams, and smaller companies began hiring their own internal recruiters. That cut transactional agencies out of the loop and moved hiring into a more direct process between employer and candidate. The shift did not eliminate agencies, but it changed which parts of the hiring cycle clients were willing to pay an external partner to run.

The post-COVID landscape: embedded recruiters and RPO

As lockdowns ended, the model did not need to change immediately. Embedded providers — supplying in-house recruiters on a monthly subscription — did well, driven by heavy hiring demand. Dangerfield notes that this was not a new arrangement; the demand simply made it more visible. With the economy now weaker, clients are confused and making more tactical hiring decisions. Two options stand out for that environment:

  • Embedded recruiter: an in-house-style recruiter supplied on a subscription basis. Fits clients who do not want to rebuild an internal team quickly but still want capacity inside their own hiring function.
  • Agency-led RPO: fits clients who prioritize volume over brand image and want an external partner to run the hiring process at scale.

Dangerfield's closing point is that survival across the cycle depends on being open to challenging past approaches that may have worked only because the market was unusually busy.

Decision checklist: which model fits the client?

Use the questions below to match a client's situation to a delivery model. The checklist is a reader aid built from the model descriptions above, not a claim about any specific client outcome.

  1. Does the client want hiring capability inside their own function, or an external partner to run it?
  • Inside → embedded recruiter.
  • External → agency-led RPO or transactional agency.
  1. Is the priority volume or brand image?
  • Volume → agency-led RPO.
  • Brand image and direct control → embedded recruiter or in-house build.
  1. Is the client ready to rebuild an internal team now?
  • Not yet → embedded recruiter on a subscription basis.
  • Yes → in-house team, with agencies used for specialist searches.
  1. Is the client's need a one-off specialist search?
  • Yes → transactional agency model.
  • No, ongoing pipeline → embedded or RPO.
  1. Is the client's budget fixed for a defined period?
  • Yes → subscription (embedded) or RPO contract with defined scope.
  • No → transactional, per-placement model.

Worked example using the 2008 shift: a large employer that had been paying a transactional agency for every role decided to build an internal team. The agency lost the recurring volume because the client moved the work in-house. A provider offering an embedded recruiter on a monthly subscription could have kept capacity inside the client's function without the client committing to a full internal build. That is the decision the checklist is designed to surface.

What stays constant across models

Whatever the delivery model, the underlying need is the same: companies keep hiring, and they need people who can engage candidates and drive the organization forward. The model choice is about who carries that work — an external agency, an embedded recruiter inside the client's function, or an RPO provider running the process at scale. Dangerfield's argument is that the model should be revisited when the market changes, not defended because it worked in a busier year.

Frequently asked questions

What is an embedded recruiter?

An embedded recruiter is a recruiter supplied to a client on a monthly subscription basis to work inside the client's hiring function. Dangerfield describes embedded providers as supplying in-house recruiters on a subscription, which lets a client add hiring capacity without rebuilding an internal team immediately.

How does an agency-led RPO differ from an embedded recruiter?

An agency-led RPO is positioned for clients who prioritize volume over brand image and want an external partner to run the hiring process. An embedded recruiter sits inside the client's function on a subscription. The choice depends on whether the client wants external process ownership at scale or in-house capacity.

Why did transactional agencies lose work after 2008?

After the 2008 recession, large organizations grew internal teams and smaller companies began hiring their own internal recruiters. That moved hiring into a more direct process and cut transactional agencies out of the loop.

Do companies stop hiring during a downturn?

Dangerfield's view is that they do not. Companies continue to hire and still need talented people to engage candidates and drive the organization forward. The change is in how they buy hiring capacity, not whether they need it.