Skip to content

Judging a Job Move for the Long Term: A Six-Factor Hiring Scorecard

A signed offer is a milestone, not proof that the hire will work out.

The harder question is whether the role will still feel right a year from now — for the candidate and for the team. This guide sets out a simple rating method for comparing jobs, a way to structure the role conversation so both sides get real information, and a follow-up step after the placement.

Why the offer is not the finish line

Recruiters often treat acceptance as the end of the process. A better test comes later: are the new hire and the client both satisfied once the person is in the role? That post-placement check is the real signal of whether the placement was a good one. The method below is built around that longer view — first for the candidate deciding whether to move, then for the employer shaping the role and the interview.

Six factors that drive job satisfaction

Lou Adler's approach asks a candidate to rate six factors on a 1–5 scale, from terrible to outstanding. The factors are compensation, the hiring manager and team, the work itself, growth opportunity, work-life balance, and company culture. The scale is: 5 outstanding, 4 very good, 3 pretty good, 2 not so good, 1 terrible.

How to read the total

Two thresholds matter. A total below roughly 14–15, or a terrible score on any single factor, is a signal to consider leaving. But leaving is not the same as having somewhere better to go: the advice is not to move until another job scores well over 20 on the same scale. Otherwise the candidate risks swapping a poor situation for one that is only marginally better.

The scorecard is most useful for comparison

The chart has value for deciding whether to quit, but its stronger use is comparing offers and judging which one is the better career move. The same evaluation applies to a counteroffer. A candidate can rate the current role and each alternative on the same six factors and compare totals and weak spots side by side.

Worked example: comparing a current role with an offer

A candidate rates their current role: compensation 4, manager and team 2, work itself 3, growth 2, work-life balance 4, culture 3 — a total of 18, with no single factor at 1. A new offer rates compensation 5, manager and team 4, work itself 4, growth 4, work-life balance 3, culture 4 — a total of 24. On the thresholds above, the current role is not in leave-now territory, but the offer clears the 'well over 20' bar. The comparison also shows where the offer is weaker: work-life balance drops by one point. That is the conversation to have before accepting, not after.

The compensation question

A useful test is to ask the candidate whether they would still want the job if compensation were not part of the picture. Most people say yes; only those genuinely drawn to the role can explain why in any detail. In Adler's experience, when the decision was made this way, compensation was usually competitive and at least four of the other five factors scored 4 or 5. In more than 90% of cases across more than 500 placements, candidates were still enthusiastic about the job at their first-year anniversary.

What employers and recruiters can do

Standard interviewing often does not give either side enough information. A performance-based job description that states the role's top objectives, combined with questions that dig into a candidate's most comparable accomplishment, gives hiring managers a way to judge whether the person can handle the role — and gives the candidate a way to judge whether the move is career-worthy. Many companies do not use this approach, so candidates end up deciding on the size of the package plus hopes and promises about the job.

A field map for the role conversation

Use these fields to structure the conversation and keep the evidence comparable:

  • Top objectives for the role: the three to five outcomes the hire must deliver in the first year.
  • Comparable accomplishment: the candidate's closest past result, with the situation, action and measurable outcome.
  • Six-factor ratings: compensation, manager and team, work itself, growth, work-life balance, culture — each scored 1–5.
  • Total and weakest factor: the sum, plus the lowest-scoring factor and why.
  • Counteroffer comparison: the same fields applied to the current role or a competing offer.
  • First-year check-in: a scheduled follow-up with the new hire and the client to confirm both are satisfied.

Advice for candidates and recruiters

For candidates: be sceptical of any decision made without the information needed for a balanced long-term view. For recruiters: reach out to candidates, explain the factors that drive career decisions, and ask for a specific explanation of what — beyond compensation — is pulling them toward the role.

Frequently asked questions

What does 'win-win hiring' mean here?

It describes an outcome where the candidate is still enthusiastic about the role a year after joining, not just at the point of accepting the offer. The six-factor rating and the performance-based role brief are the tools used to aim for that outcome.

Should I leave my job if my score is low?

A total below about 14–15, or a terrible score on any single factor, is a reason to consider leaving. The advice is not to move until another job scores well over 20 on the same scale, so the move is a genuine improvement rather than a marginal one.

Can I use the same scorecard for a counteroffer?

Yes. Rate the current role and the counteroffer on the same six factors and compare totals and weak spots. The scorecard is most valuable for comparing alternatives, not just for deciding whether to quit.

What can employers do to make the decision better for candidates?

Write a performance-based job description that states the role's top objectives, and interview around the candidate's most comparable accomplishment. That gives both sides the information needed to judge whether the role is a good long-term fit.