Five practical moves to move diversity hiring beyond tokenism
Many organisations start diversity work with sincere intent, yet settle for visible gestures that change little.
Recruitment thought leader Jennifer Tardy, founder of Jennifer Tardy Consulting, outlines a more demanding approach: question who is missing, follow people after they join, test whether effort produces results, map representation across the whole organisation, and stop hiding gaps inside broad demographic categories.
1. Reimagine who representation should include
Start by questioning the usual targets. Hiring more women may be one goal, but it can obscure other groups that remain underrepresented inside the company or among its customers. Identify those specific populations first, then design outreach, criteria and partnerships around the gaps actually found. A useful check is to list, for each major function, which groups are absent or scarce before setting any numerical ambition.
2. Connect hiring with retention and promotion
A hire is only the beginning. Compare joining and leaving patterns for underrepresented employees, and ask whether they have real choice over their direction and advancement. If departures rise soon after arrival, the problem may be belonging, management, workload or blocked progression rather than attraction. Treat hiring, staying and moving up as one system, because an inclusive culture must operate after the offer letter.
3. Audit whether effort matches outcomes
Intent needs a test. Review applicant data stage by stage to find where historically underrepresented candidates drop out or fail to advance, then remove the barriers behind those patterns. Sourcing from a wider range of groups and regions can widen the pool, but it only helps when selection and promotion outcomes are monitored against the original purpose.
4. Map representation across every level
Do not judge the whole company from one department. Examine representation across business units, departments and seniority levels to learn whether underrepresentation is widespread or concentrated in particular areas. That distinction changes the remedy: a company-wide pattern calls for system-wide change, while a localised gap may need targeted work on roles, managers or career routes in that sector.
5. Separate demographic data before drawing conclusions
Broad groupings can create a flattering but misleading picture. For example, people of colour taken together may appear well represented, while Black and Latinx employees are underrepresented and Asian employees are overrepresented. Separating the data respects different experiences and exposes the real gap. Bundling figures to support a preferred story risks erasing those differences, much like treating everyone the same.
A simple decision checklist
Use these five moves as a sequence rather than a slogan. Define the missing groups, check whether they stay and advance, audit each hiring stage, map the pattern by unit and level, and keep demographic categories distinct. Research, clear processes and accountability turn that sequence into progress. Tardy also points readers to the Increase Diversity newsletter on LinkedIn for deeper discussion with recruiters and hiring teams.
About the author
Jennifer Tardy is a recruitment thought leader and founder of Jennifer Tardy Consulting, also known as Team JTC. Since 2004, her mission has been to help employers and job seekers meet their goals while making increasing diversity make sense and cents. Through #HiringSuccess programs, Team JTC helps employers find, attract, engage and hire more applicants from historically underrepresented backgrounds, encouraging open discussion of underrepresentation, removal of hiring inequalities and more inclusive work cultures. As a Career Success Coach, Tardy also supports job seekers through #CareerSuccess, drawing on knowledge of barriers faced by women, people of color, people with disabilities, veterans and people who identify as LGBTQ+ to help candidates overcome bias-driven hiring obstacles and access greater opportunities.
Frequently asked questions
Why is aligning intentions with hiring outcomes necessary?
Good intentions do not change who gets hired or promoted. Audit applicant and outcome data, look for obstacles affecting historically underrepresented groups, and then adjust processes so results match the stated goal.
What does decoupling demographic data reveal?
A combined category can look balanced while hiding gaps inside it. Looking at each group separately reveals distinct experiences and where representation is actually low or high.
Why look beyond recruiting when improving diversity?
Recruiting alone will not sustain diversity if people leave quickly or lack control over their career paths. Retention and promotion need the same attention as hiring, supported by an inclusive culture.