Overcoming hiring challenges: too many candidates, too few, bias and red flags
Every hiring market looks different, yet the same pressure points keep returning.
Ellie Rankin Dailey, Senior Talent Partner at Russell Tobin, groups them into volume, bias and candidate fit — then adds a practical note on using technology and professional communities without losing the human side of recruiting.
Why the same challenges keep appearing
Recruiting varies by sector, employer and vacancy, and no two candidates arrive with the same background. What connects recruiters is the recurring difficulty of matching the right person to the right role under time pressure.
Three challenges appear repeatedly: sourcing qualified people, keeping decisions free from unconscious bias, and telling a genuine fit from a poor one. Ellie Rankin Dailey's advice treats each as a process problem first and a people problem second — which is why the remedies focus on structure, clarity and evidence rather than instinct alone.
Challenge 1: Too many candidates or not enough
Most vacancies fall into one of two situations: an empty pipeline or an overflowing one. Naming which situation you are in determines the next move.
If there are too many candidates, the work becomes logistical. Interview scheduling, CV scanning and keeping applicants informed all need a system. Set interview windows and deadlines in advance, sort candidates against clear criteria, and communicate next steps so people are not left waiting. High volume rewards organisation and strategy, not faster improvisation.
If there are too few candidates, the search can turn into a hunt for an unrealistic profile. Demanding requirements from the hiring manager and low brand awareness are common causes. Make the role more attractive by being explicit about flexibility, growth opportunities and other benefits. Consider remote hiring and opening the position to a wider geographic pool to reach more prospective candidates.
Challenge 2: Unconscious bias
Unconscious bias can enter hiring decisions even when nobody intends it to. Human brains are wired to favour familiar patterns, so goodwill and diversity initiatives do not remove the risk on their own.
The practical counterweight is standardisation. Use the same core questions, the same scoring criteria and the same process for every candidate, so fairness does not depend on who happens to be in the room. Train the hiring team and agree non-negotiable expectations before interviews begin. That combination — shared criteria plus explicit accountability — spreads awareness and makes equal treatment the default.
Challenge 3: Identifying red flags
Recruiters usually have a clear picture of the ideal candidate, but far less guidance on who to rule out. A useful test is to dig into motivation first: why has this person applied for this role?
Motivation tied mainly to a job title, money, recognition or a particular brand is a reason to be cautious. By contrast, candidates who speak about their own growth and explain how their skills can benefit the organisation give a stronger signal. A second check is preparation. Someone who cannot share basic knowledge about the organisation has probably not invested enough in the role to be a serious fit.
Use this quick red-flag check before progressing a candidate:
- Can they explain why they want this role, beyond title, pay or brand?
- Can they describe how their skills would help this organisation?
- Do they know the basics of the organisation and the role?
- Is their interest in growth and contribution clear and specific?
If several answers are vague or missing, pause and gather more evidence rather than relying on a first impression.
Technology and community in modern recruiting
Compared with a decade ago, recruiting tools have changed how work gets done and made many tasks more manageable. Social recruiting and technology have opened new hiring practices, and networking plus industry knowledge are now easier to access.
For a new recruiter, the most useful advice is to join communities and groups and learn from experienced practitioners. Approach that network in a friendly, generous way — the whale rather than the shark — and the expertise around you becomes a genuine resource for understanding the industry and improving each hire.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between having too many candidates and too few?
When applications flood in, the bottleneck shifts to scheduling, scanning CVs and replying to everyone waiting for an update. When applications are scarce, the bottleneck shifts to sourcing — often because requirements are narrow or the employer is not well known. The response differs: organise the first, widen and strengthen the offer for the second.
How do you reduce unconscious bias if it is unintentional?
Standardise the process so every candidate is judged against the same criteria, train the hiring team, and set expectations that are not optional. Awareness alone is not enough; a consistent structure is what makes fairness repeatable.
What should a recruiter check before treating a candidate as a red flag?
Ask why the person wants the role and whether they know the organisation. Motivation centred only on title, pay, recognition or brand, and little basic knowledge of the employer, are treated as warning signs. Stronger signals are a clear interest in growth and a concrete view of how their skills help the organisation.