Skip to content

Retaining Women Managers: The Great Breakup Explained

The Great Breakup describes a pattern in which women leaders leave their organisations at higher rates than men at the same level.

It is not a single event but a set of pressures that accumulate: slights that undercut authority, extra unpaid work that goes unrecognised, and a search for a culture that matches stated values. This guide separates the causes and gives a checklist for the retention actions that address each one.

Why women leaders leave

The Women in the Workplace Report 2022, published by LeanIn.Org and McKinsey & Co., is the reference point for this pattern. Its central finding is that women leaders want to advance at similar rates to men, but are more likely to switch employers to get what they need. Three pressures recur.

1. Microaggressions that erode authority. Women managers are more likely than men to have their judgement questioned or to hear that they lack the qualifications for their role. They are also more likely to say that personal characteristics — gender, or being a parent — played a part in being passed over for a raise, promotion or stretch assignment. The cumulative effect is a signal that advancement will be harder here than elsewhere.

2. Overwork that is not counted. Women executives spend more time than men at their level on diversity, equity and inclusion work and on employee well-being. That work improves retention and satisfaction, but in most organisations it is not formally recognised. Time spent on unacknowledged work is time not spent on the visible work that drives promotion, which makes the path upward slower and the burnout risk higher.

3. A search for a better culture. Women are more likely than men to leave in order to gain more freedom or to join an organisation more committed to DE&I. Women leaders also invest more in people management, allyship and DE&I than men at the same level, which means they are often the ones building the inclusive workplace that younger workers expect. When that effort is not matched by the employer, leaving becomes the rational move.

A retention checklist for women managers

The two levers below are the ones the report identifies as most consequential. Use the checklist to decide which applies before committing budget.

Lever 1 — Make flexibility real, not a stigma. Interest in flexible work is higher than ever, and most employees prefer remote or hybrid arrangements. More than 70% of businesses report that offering these options helped them hire and keep people from underrepresented groups. But remote work is not a universal fix. If women use it to escape a toxic office, they miss the networking and visibility that lead to promotion, and the arrangement can become a track that separates men in the office from women at home. The test is whether flexibility is used by everyone at every level, and whether promotion decisions are made on output rather than presence.

Lever 2 — Support managers so they can support people. Women report less burnout and lower intent to leave when their managers invest in DE&I and people management. Yet there is a gap between what managers are asked to do and how they are trained and rewarded. Fewer than half of women say their manager takes an interest in their career or helps manage workload, and only about half say their manager consistently supports courteous behaviour. Training managers to run inclusive remote and hybrid teams is a practical first step. Employees who can choose how they work are less likely to burn out, happier in their roles, and significantly less likely to consider leaving.

Worked example: the unrecognised DE&I workload

Consider a manager who chairs the inclusion committee, mentors two junior women and handles the team's well-being check-ins. None of this appears in her objectives. Her male peer at the same level spends the same hours on client delivery, which does appear. At review time the peer has a stronger visible record, even though both worked comparable hours. The retention fix is not to ask her to do less inclusion work; it is to write that work into goals, evaluation criteria and reward decisions so that it counts. If the organisation cannot name who owns that change, the workload will keep falling on the same people and the departure risk will remain.

The failure distinction: when flexibility backfires

A remote policy can look like progress while producing the opposite result. The failure mode is a policy that is available on paper but carries a cost in practice: those who use it are seen as less committed, are passed over for stretch work, or miss the informal conversations where promotions are decided. The report warns that flexible work can be misused to marginalise women and people with disabilities, and that women may choose home to avoid a toxic culture, losing networking and career-progression visibility as a result. The distinction to hold is between flexibility as an option everyone uses and flexibility as a place where one group is parked. If men are in the office and women are not, the policy is not retaining women; it is slowing them down.

What to measure and who owns it

Retention work fails when no one owns the numbers. The map below links each driver to a measure and an accountable role. Treat the measures as a starting set to adapt, not a fixed scorecard.

  • Microaggressions — measure: share of women managers reporting judgement questioned or qualifications doubted; owner: HR business partner with the relevant department head.
  • Unrecognised DE&I and well-being work — measure: whether that work appears in objectives and review criteria; owner: reward and performance lead.
  • Manager support — measure: share of women who say their manager takes an interest in their career and helps with workload; owner: people-manager training lead.
  • Flexibility stigma — measure: promotion rates for those who use flexible arrangements versus those who do not; owner: talent review panel.
  • Burnout and intent to stay — measure: burnout prevalence and stated likelihood of leaving among women managers; owner: HR analytics, reported to the executive team.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Great Breakup?

It is the pattern, documented in the Women in the Workplace Report 2022 by LeanIn.Org and McKinsey & Co., in which women leaders leave their employers at higher rates than men at the same level, largely because they are seeking more from work than their current organisation provides.

Do women managers want promotion as much as men?

Yes. Women managers are just as likely as men to want to advance into senior positions. The difference is that they are more likely to change employer to get there when the current workplace does not support them.

Is offering remote work enough to retain women managers?

No. Remote and hybrid options can help, and more than 70% of businesses report that they helped hire and keep people from underrepresented groups. But if flexibility becomes a stigma and women miss networking and visibility, it can slow promotion rather than prevent departure.

What should managers do differently?

Managers should take an active interest in each person's career, help manage workload and model courteous behaviour. Training managers to run inclusive remote and hybrid teams is a practical first step, because women report less burnout and lower intent to leave when their managers invest in people management and DE&I.