Skip to content

Creative Alignments: Making a Custom Recruitment Workflow Easier to Run

Creative Alignments built its business around a time-based billing model, a deliberate departure from traditional contingency search.

That model lets clients make multiple hires from one search without additional expense, but it created a practical problem: off-the-shelf applicant tracking systems were not designed around it. As the firm grew, even basic candidate searches became slow, and several alternative tools proved too complicated for recruiters to use consistently.

The real problem was fit, not just features

The firm had operated for more than a decade with its distinctive approach, yet its tracking system could not keep pace. Searching for candidates took too long, and the tools the team tried in response added complexity rather than removing it. Dee Ryan, Client Services Director at Creative Alignments, summed up the adoption problem plainly: earlier ATS solutions were complicated, and recruiters were not using them.

That distinction matters. The issue was not simply a missing feature. A system that recruiters avoid creates incomplete records, inconsistent follow-up and weak visibility for managers, even if its feature list looks complete on paper.

What stood out during evaluation

After earlier disappointments, the team approached a new demo cautiously. What changed their view was the combination of a highly adaptable setup, a clean interface and a realistic prospect of recruiters actually adopting it. Ryan recalled being excited by the demonstration, while also noting that it initially seemed almost too good to be true.

Use this as an evaluation checklist for any ATS shortlist:

  • Can custom fields reflect how your firm actually works, rather than a generic template?
  • Can workflows be adjusted for different clients or search types?
  • Can a recruiter find and update a candidate without unnecessary steps?
  • Will managers be able to see client activity and pipeline status without manual workarounds?
  • Is support available after implementation, when adoption habits are still forming?

Three priorities that shaped the decision

Customization was the first priority. The team could add custom fields and adjust workflows around particular client needs. Ryan explained that other systems had not matched the business, while this one showed clear potential to do so. For a firm whose service model depends on flexibility, that was more than a convenience: it protected the consistency of the approach the firm had used for over a decade.

Simplicity was the second priority. In a fast-moving recruitment environment, a crowded or confusing interface slows every search, update and follow-up. The cleaner design helped recruiters adapt quickly and return their attention to placement work instead of navigating the tool.

The third priority was practical recruiter support. Features were valued when they addressed everyday work, including candidate tracking and communication, rather than adding abstract functionality. The result was a workflow the team could use more effectively while focusing on service quality.

What changed in day-to-day work

Following implementation, recruiters became more engaged with the system, and managers gained better visibility into client activities and pipelines. Ryan described the integration as strengthening an approach that had already been consistent for more than ten years. Support after implementation was highlighted as an important factor in lifting adoption.

The lesson extends beyond one firm: when a recruitment model is unusual, the ATS should be tested against that model, recruiter behaviour and management visibility together. A tool that can be customized but not easily used may still fail, while a simple tool that cannot reflect the workflow will eventually create workarounds.

A practical test before you switch

If your current ATS struggles with candidate search, cannot accommodate your billing or service model, or is being avoided by recruiters, treat those as signs to reassess the fit. Start by mapping your non-negotiable workflow, then test whether custom fields, workflow controls and the everyday interface support it. A demo should include the tasks recruiters perform most often, not only a feature tour.

Frequently asked questions

Why did a standard ATS not fit Creative Alignments?

Creative Alignments uses a time-based billing model rather than traditional contingency search, and wanted a system that could be shaped around that approach instead of forcing the team into a standard workflow.

What made adoption difficult before the change?

Earlier systems were described as complicated and were not being used consistently by recruiters. A simpler interface and easier adaptation were therefore treated as adoption requirements, not cosmetic preferences.

What role did customization play?

Custom fields and workflows tailored to specific client needs were the central example. That flexibility let the team keep its established approach while making each client engagement more specific.

What changed after implementation?

Recruiters reported stronger engagement after implementation, while management gained clearer visibility into client activities and pipelines. Post-implementation support was also credited with helping adoption.